Aaron Hernandez - Guilty Again

On March 13, 2019 the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts reinstated the murder conviction of the former New England Patriot Aaron Hernandez. This decision overturned the common law doctrine in Massachusetts of abatement ab initio, which allowed a criminal defendant's conviction to be vacated if he or she passed away while a direct appeal was pending.

Aaron Hernandez was originally convicted of first degree murder on April 15, 2015 in Bristol County Superior Court. The verdict was appealed by Hernandez. While the appeal was pending, Hernandez passed away while in prison, in what was widely believed to be a suicide. As a result of his death, The Superior Court held that the convictions were to be vacated under the doctrine of abatement ab initio.

In the Supreme Judicial Court's recent decision, it was held that that this doctrine should no longer apply in Massachusetts. The justices analyzed the history of the rarely used doctrine, and determined that it should no longer apply in Massachusetts. As such, Hernandez is once again a convicted felon. This is likely to have a number consequences to Hernandez' estate and the families of the victims of his crimes.

Legally, this case shows that even seemingly well-established legal doctrines can be changed in a criminal appeal. Where a trial court made an incorrect legal decision, or a decision that is otherwise likely to be overturned on appeal, it is always wise to consider an appeal. Although Hernandez' conviction was reinstated, for most convicted defendants, an appeal can potentially result in the overturning of a conviction, or the right to be given a new trial. If you or a loved one have been convicted and believe there are issues that should be appealed, you should contact an experienced criminal appeals lawyer today to preserve your appellate rights.

Related Posts
  • $80M Award: Roundup Causes Cancer Read More
  • General Continuance and Pre-Trial Probation Read More
  • New Rules for Arrests and Free Speech Read More
  • Accessible, Appreciative, & Attentive

    We appreciate the opportunity to help clients during times of need and turmoil. We treat each case as if it was our own and are always happy to guide our clients.

  • Passionate, Prudent & Professional

    Being passionate about the law and helping our clients allows us to work prudently, and professionally to achieve your goals.

  • Compassionate, Capable, & Conscientous

    When you are facing a legal issue, we will be there with you every step of the way. We will fight for you and we will advocate for you.

  • Objective, Organized, & Open-Minded

    We always look at the big picture to help you make the right decisions about your case. We are always learning and are never too proud to take the actions necessary to effectuate our clients' goals.

Ready to Get Started? Contact Us Today